Logitech G19

Diablo

Active member
Logitech G19:

So you have the fastest quad core money can buy, overclocked to the max. You have the latest graphics chips and watercooling, but you are still using the same budget keyboard that came with your old pc five years ago.

It is a situation that many of us enthusiasts find ourselves in. We spend hundreds (or thousands) on the latest high spec components but skimp on the bits that we use the most. The keyboard and mouse.

It has been well understood that a good mouse can make a huge difference in a gamer's score, but a keyboard has never been so important. I mean, one keyboard is much the same as another right?

With Razer and Logitech seemingly fairly in control of the higher end of the market, it seems now might be a good time to look at Logitech's latest offering, the G19. Those of you who have been around for a while may remember the G15, which one of the first (if not the first) to feature an LCD screen. It was backlit in orange, featured 6 macro keys (rev. 2) which could be programmed to execute a series of commands at the touch of a button.

The packaging of the G19 is reasonably restrained, with the usual Logitech G series colours and the back devoted to the features. The keyboard was adequately packaged, but I get the feeling a courier would have no problem destroying it.

P8110275-1.jpg


P8110273.jpg


So now we come on to the G19. It seems Logitech took on board some of the users ideas and have totally redesigned the G19. This keyboard features back-lit keys, in almost any shade, 12 macro keys, media keys, a switch to lock the windows key off during games, a volume control switch and best of all, a 240*320 colour screen.

All of this has a price. While the G15 was a mere £50 or £60, its new big brother is £120. In addition, the USB connection can no longer support the additional power needed by the screen. An additional power supply from the mains is provided, which adds new clutter under your desk.

Perhaps, this would be a good time to say some of the other features. This model has a wrist rest, can act as a powered USB hub with two USB 2.0 slots in built. No audio pass through is included unfortunately.

The G (macro) keys can be programmed on the fly, or using the software. There are also three modes which the keyboard can be put into, which changes the programming of the G keys and changes the backlighting colour to that which you set in the software. Those of you familiar with the G9 mouse will be used to the range of colours available. The backlighting is not overly bright, although it can be turned off entirely it cannot be dimmed, except for picking a darker shade in the software.

l_g19kb.jpg


Typing has a nice feel, with the keys being nice to touch, with a slightly rubbery coating and making a quiet but effective sounds when hit, which leaves you in no doubt as to whether a key has been hit. The keys are full travel (not laptop style) and are membrane sprung . The keyboard is 49cm long, which is only 5cm longer than a generic OEM keyboard.

Now we look at the screen. It has the same resolution of an iPod classic, is about 2.5" and has a decent backlight, which can be tweaked. It is also full colour, allowing it to watch MP4 movies on your computer on the little screen. (Loading screens aren't nearly as bad with Lord of the Rings on). It can also browse bits of youtube, read RSS feeds (including everybody's favourite reviews site's RSS feeds), all programmable through the software. In addition there are a few in built programs such as the media display, which shows what is playing, allowing easy control of it through the media keys. Other programs include a performance monitor for CPUs, a clock, a picture viewer and additional programs such as Windows sideshow programs.

This enables the user to check email, look at their calendar and browse their windows media player library. Yes it is possible to check your email mid Crysis! (Although it must be your inbox, not in a sub folder).

l_g19screen.jpg


Some programs also have the addition to display information onto the G19, although so far almost all of these seem to be for the G15, hence are monochrome. Core temp is a nicety, as is Crysis. More programs will support this as time goes on and the user base develop programs.

So we come onto my conclusion. There is one issue I've found, which is that the computer sometimes can't recognise the keyboard, although as it is through a USB hub, the hub may be the issue. Apart from that, I love this keyboard. Now I have the screen, I find it more difficult to use a pc without it. The keyboard is very good, it performs well and is well built, has many features and looks great. The bad news is the price. For this money, you could get two razer keyboards, or a Saitek Eclipse III and a gaming mouse of your choice (except the mamba), but if you have to have the best, this is the one for you.

Overall, 9.5/10 for performance, 6/10 for value and 10/10 for presentation.
 
Nice review, I dont think I would ever pay that extra cash for a LCD on my keyborad when you have a monitor, I would of gone with the G110.
 
All I can really say is that for gaming not enough developers put enough effort into creating interfaces for the screen. I've only seen one semi-decent interface and that was in Borderlands, of all things. While I definitely recommend a fully-lit keyboard for all-purpose keyboard use in the dark, the practical uses for the screen can certainly be questioned. It's comfortable, it's interesting and is only really as useful as you decide to make it. It should also be noted that it suffers from the sniffles if you boot up your PC whilst the keyboard itself is booting (for example, turning the power on at the socket), leaving your pretty colours and configurations in an odd stasis for a while.
 
All I can really say is that for gaming not enough developers put enough effort into creating interfaces for the screen. I've only seen one semi-decent interface and that was in Borderlands, of all things. While I definitely recommend a fully-lit keyboard for all-purpose keyboard use in the dark, the practical uses for the screen can certainly be questioned. It's comfortable, it's interesting and is only really as useful as you decide to make it. It should also be noted that it suffers from the sniffles if you boot up your PC whilst the keyboard itself is booting (for example, turning the power on at the socket), leaving your pretty colours and configurations in an odd stasis for a while.

The screen isn't useful at all... its just cool to have.
wink.gif
 
All a gaming keyboard needs is anti-ghosting, reasonable comfort and durability. Extra buttons and backlighting are a bonus.
 
The screen isn't useful at all... its just cool to have.
wink.gif

Completely depends. Sure, if you're playing games in Steam it renders whatever uses it has kind of redundant. If you play games in the dark you can quickly check the time, perhaps leave little notes for yourself via the picture viewer, watch any helpful videos you've downloaded if you don't trust Steam's web browser etc. If developers did more with it it could potentially be a lot more useful, but in the best case scenario it'll be a pretty, yet insipid way to browse through statistics and such, which could help, seeing as most UIs in games seem to be a little icky.
 
I actually quite like the display on my g15. It's very useful for monitoring temps. I also use the media display to find out what I'm listening to xD
 
IMHO a BIG waste that little display
tongue.gif


and you seriously pay 30/50 more for that little part , that is def not worth that money !
 
IMHO a BIG waste that little display
tongue.gif


and you seriously pay 30/50 more for that little part , that is def not worth that money !

End of the day I can't disagree. Having the keys lit up is nice but there are cheaper keyboards for that.
 
Depends what you want. Now that AIDA 64 has decent compatability, I use the screen pretty much all the time to monitor all the temps and voltages etc. Again, that's because having those stats in front of me is useful to me. Sure its expensive, but it's what I use all the time, and I'm pretty comfortable with it. If you are here to debate value for money, this isn't the keyboard for you, simple as.
 
No no no you got me wrong maybe 'cause I didn't phrase it properly.I ment this keyboard is overpriced only 'cause of it's colour lcd.The 510 has same features,including the awesome barrel volume control thingy,also extra 6 G keys which gives you 18 extra binding options.

Also if i'm not wrong the lcd on 510 can display the same info the G19 does(well obviously excluding the youtube).

So basically the 510 has more keys,same features,a whole lot cheaper,which makes it a better option for me but,I still can't decide which to get between the two.

I'm not sure about the on board sound card and the USB ports though.
 
One of my computers has the G15. I don't find myself looking at the screen all that frequently. Seems a waste to put it on a keyboard. Too low
biggrin.gif


Maybe I just haven't found the right use for it yet.
 
I have the G15 and love the display, its great for seeing whos talking on TS or vent during game play. Plus all the other plugins! id pay extra just for that!
 
Looks like a brill Keyboard
smile.gif
. I have the G510 myself and I'm loving it so far. Logitech are awesome with regards to their computer peripherals (of course that is my opinion).
 
Two years later, I have updated the pictures.

I would also like to add the following:

Aida 64 is the program this keyboard has been waiting for. Logitech + Itunes does not work (google itunes media keys), and logitech's coders appear to think testing is completely optional, although the latest driver build is a lot more stable.
 
Back
Top