Based on tonight:
Wrong choice in goal, of the three keepers of limited quality, James is the best (biased as I am a pompey fan) and on a night where experience and commitment count for a lot, Carson was the wrongest choice.
However, poor tactics, hitting the ball to Crouch at the first chance doesn't work and won't work.
Shaun WP and Joe Cole could beat their full backs all day but their deliveries were non-existent. David Beckham showed with one cross how he is infinitely better than SWP.
In the end Croatia knew exactly what to do, exactly how they should play. They played better football, a system their players looked comfortable playing. England looked clueless as to how to play and it showed. Croatia are, man for man, not as skilled as the England players on the night, exception being Wayne Bridge and Steven Gerrard, who were both tragically poor. They came to win. And with some fortune they did, they made substitutions at the right times, the fresh pair of legs at 2-2 I think was the difference and a nicely timed goal from him too, again Carson was to blame.
However the England managers job is now a very unattractive proposition, as effectively there is nothing to do for a year until qualification again starts. The man who may be able to do the job Martin O'Niell has only been at Villa 18 months. Quite why he would leave them to do nothing for a year I don't see.
Steve McLaren, if sacked, can look back and see that he was unlucky with injuries. Bad fortune in the goalkeeping department. But at the end of the day, we'd rather be very lucky and qualified.