That's the problem for me, I don't find these scary games and films actually scary since most of them are just cheap jump scares, and don't actually get you scared.
The last time I was actually scared by a film was Jurassic Park and I was 8 when I watched that the first time, and it didn't scare me watching the film it was after it when I got home and went to bed, because me and my brother had a walk in wardrobe in our room, and we had a Dinasour teddy in it.