Need feedback

[RamboOC]

I need feedback for my new signature so that I know how to improve it. Criticize as much as you want :

 

[Davva2004]

Looks good to me, as long as you like it you're good to go.

 

[RamboOC]

it says "This image has been resized. Click this bar to view the full image."
looks like im going to have to resize it

 

[MadShadow]

Looks nice! If I were to judge anything, it would be that the colours don't match that well, but honestly, it looks great.

 

[maniac]

Check the Signature Service thread for the actual sizing of the sigs to not be resized.

 

[tinytomlogan]

Just need to make it a bit narrower so it doesnt get resized

 

[Remmy]

How about including your PSU and case? I'm not sure if I'd prefer the text centred rather than left justified, play around with it and see which you prefer.

Also, when you put it in your signature, I'd centre the image.

 

[RamboOC]

Just need to make it a bit narrower so it doesnt get resized

will do, thanks

How about including your PSU and case? I'm not sure if I'd prefer the text centred rather than left justified, play around with it and see which you prefer.

Also, when you put it in your signature, I'd centre the image.

Almost forgot about psu, thanks

 

[SuB]

honest feedback?
(pre-emptively apologising, but it's my job (at work) to be critical of stuff)


...okay...


That font is horrific... I assume the background is from an nVidia one (I think I recognise it) this clashes with the blue and red of the logo pretty badly (which is also a substandard bastardisation if you ask me)

Which leads me to your avatar.. also a sub-standard over-compressed bastardisation

Finally, you're from the UK we spell it "Criticise"

Sorry!

 

[RamboOC]

Here is the version after few fixes
edit: still resizes

honest feedback?
(pre-emptively apologising, but it's my job (at work) to be critical of stuff)


...okay...


That font is horrific... I assume the background is from an nVidia one (I think I recognise it) this clashes with the blue and red of the logo pretty badly (which is also a substandard bastardisation if you ask me)

Which leads me to your avatar.. also a sub-standard over-compressed bastardisation

Finally, you're from the UK we spell it "Criticise"

Sorry!

I will work on the font and colours clashing

 

[RamboOC]

which one looks the best?

Or this :

 

[Remmy]

I'd say the second one down. I'd still think it would look better with the text centred, mainly because of the middle line being shorter.

That fourth one is stunning, we need to start rolling it out forum-wide :L

 

[SuB]

heh, I love it when people who 'design' try and be funny with overtly over the top sarcasm. Makes me chuckle.

Of the 3 non-piss-take ones, the top one looks the 'best'. (But still, in my genuine and honest opinion, the best of what I'd consider to be 'first-draft' set of images)