Intel E5200 Review

cl0ck_ed

New member
E52002.jpg


Ok, previously to purchasing this cpu I had a E4300 which I had clocked at 3.51ghz. It was a great cpu, I was just hungry for the power that these new Wolfdale cores offer.

The Intel E5200 is a stripped down Wolfdale cpu with just 2Mb of level two cache, compared to the 3Mb of the E7x00 series and 6Mb of the E8x00 series.

The E5200 is marketed as a budget cpu under the Pentium branding. Though the cpu has exactly the same architecture as its bigger brother in the Core 2 Duo range such as the E8600.

The E5200 has a stock clock of 2.5ghz and the VID of my chip is 1.225v.

Overclocking:

Overclocking the cpu was very simple, many beginners are afraid of breaking there computers, but with some common sense not much can go wrong.

Keeping the cpu in Intels safe voltage range of 1.375v this cpu generally achieves 3.6ghz-4ghz.

I took the chip up past 3.5ghz with little effort. Cooler of the chip is through the means of Water, with a D-Tek FuZion at the heart of the system.

I put 1.55v into the chip to see how far I could go. For a 24/7 voltage this is quite a lot, but heat is the main factor that kills cpus, so I was happy putting that amount of voltage into the chip as the temperature never goes above about 60c.

Maximum overclock achieved is 4.35ghz.

e5200435ghz16v.jpg


24/7 clock is 4.175ghz @ 1.55v in bios.

Below shows the benefits of overclocking the cpu in a gaming situation. Gaming is the most cpu intensive task I use my computer for, so the truth in the pudding is how well it games ;)



In particular my favourite game COD4.

Test setup:

E5200 @ stock 2.5ghz

E5200 @ 4.175ghz

8800gts @ stock

8800gts @ 684, 1036

4gb Ballistix ram

Asus commando mobo.

17" monitor @1280x1024

Test game: COD4 @ 1280x1024 @ max settings.

Results:

FPS recorded using fraps, for 7mins, on crossfire map multiplayer.

E5200@2.5ghz 8800gts stock

Frames: 24238 - Time: 207846ms - Avg: 116.615 - Min: 41 - Max: 236

E5200@2.5ghz 8800gts oc

Frames: 57159 - Time: 420000ms - Avg: 136.093 - Min: 67 - Max: 251

E5200@4.175ghz 8800gts oc

Frames: 80153 - Time: 420000ms - Avg: 190.840 - Min: 69 - Max: 253



comparison.jpg




Ok, the results speak a thousand words.

Overclocking the graphics card increased the min fps dramatically 63% improvement. The average and the max fps also improved considerably.

With the cpu overclocking, the minimum fps only improved by 2 fps, showing that the cpu doesn't bottleneck the min fps. As well, the max fps is also only 2fps better; this shows that the gfx card is at its maximum potential.

Edit: Max fps was set to 249 in game to prevent being kicked from servers. When i set it to 999 the fps spikes up to about 370fps.

What’s really impressive is that the average fps has improved from the stock clocked results with oc card by 55%. This is VERY noticeable in game play, as the motion feels much more fluid.


Here is the Wprime 32m calc:

realnicewprime.jpg


Super Pi calc:

quickerpi.jpg


All in all the E5200 is an excellent cpu for a general pc user, and has plenty of power for gaming.

If anybody wants to build a gaming pc, I’d suggest buying this cpu and spending the majority of your money on a fast graphics card.

Here is a massively impressive gaming pc for under £500. Note windows also needed.

basket.jpg


I can't stress enough how good this chip really is. It offers fantastic value for money, and after some light or heavy ;) overclocking unleashes a mighty powerful processor, which is capable of the most demanding tasks.

I'm sure you'll all be amazed at the power the little budget chip can punch, and I hope you all enjoy reading this as much as i have writing it.

Ed

 
Excellent review.

I like this chip and I might be considering it now thanks to you. :D

[Partly offtopic]Your choice of products for the £500 budget are good but the GTX260 will be bottle necked.[/Partly offtopic]
 
Nice little review. I have an E5200 myself and it loves to overclock although my Striker Extreme (680i) is holding it back. The next time I want to have some fun, I'll bung it into my P35 and see what I can do with it!

My Striker has some serious Vdroop issues which doesn't allow me to overclock very well!

Just for your info, running it at 1.55v is going to kill it. They are 45nm chips and they do not like the volts!
 
@zak4994

From this review I tried to show that when the E5200 is overclocked, it will not bottleneck a good gpu. Most people with these chips manage 4ghz on 1.4v. Which will not bottleneck a fast gpu like the gtx260 much at all.

The E8400 that is £90 more may be able to overclock to 4.5ghz but the advantage of the extra mhz after the 4ghz boundary will really diminish.

What i'm saying is that money is better spent on the gpu if gaming is the most important task on your pc. For example:

Intel E5200 £57.37

GTX 260 216core £159

Total= £216.37

Vs

Intel E8400 £140.24

Ati HD4830 £80.37

Total= £220.61

Ok, this is a simple one. Which of the two systems will perform better? the answer is the E5200 system for gaming. The money is far better spent on a fast gpu rather than a cpu. As long as you clock the cpu to 3.5-4ghz there will be little bottleneck if any. The only reason I can think of to get the E8x00 series cpu is to get a high super pi score which thrives on the 6mb cache.
 
name='cl0ck_ed' said:
@zak4994

From this review I tried to show that when the E5200 is overclocked, it will not bottleneck a good gpu. Most people with these chips manage 4ghz on 1.4v. Which will not bottleneck a fast gpu like the gtx260 much at all.

The E8400 that is £90 more may be able to overclock to 4.5ghz but the advantage of the extra mhz after the 4ghz boundary will really diminish.

What i'm saying is that money is better spent on the gpu if gaming is the most important task on your pc. For example:

Intel E5200 £57.37

GTX 260 216core £159

Total= £216.37

Vs

Intel E8400 £140.24

Ati HD4830 £80.37

Total= £220.61

Ok, this is a simple one. Which of the two systems will perform better? the answer is the E5200 system for gaming. The money is far better spent on a fast gpu rather than a cpu. As long as you clock the cpu to 3.5-4ghz there will be little bottleneck if any. The only reason I can think of to get the E8x00 series cpu is to get a high super pi score which thrives on the 6mb cache.

I was talking about it being at the stock clock.

But for overclocked, awesome.
 
Greta review. I was thinking that if this chip was a good clocker it was amazing value. Nice to know that it does perform. I bet that it would make the basis for a great 24/7 folding rig as well.
 
Nice review, just got one for a new build on the family computer at home. Hopefully it'll clock something close :)

What kind of temps does it hit?
 
Nice review - I was just browing the forums and noticed this thread.

Just got my e5200 through the post today, I'm using it to revive some components I've gained over the past few weeks (mobo, PSU, GPU). It'll be forming a "project" & media center rig.

Cheers for the review.

James
 
name='ali_james' said:
Nice review, just got one for a new build on the family computer at home. Hopefully it'll clock something close :)

What kind of temps does it hit?

Temps, wise it never goes above 60c on my wc. The temp probes are abit rubbish on the chip. At 2.5ghz to 4.35 ghz, the temp doesn't change at idle.

At 4ghz, idleing at 35ish, which is tha same for any frequency.
 
Scan have finally cottoned onto the power of the pentium E5200! Almost the same spec that i proposed 2 months or so ago. For £500 excl monitor etc.

PCOTM_TC.jpg


http://3xs.scan.co.uk/ShowSystem.asp?SystemID=988

Case 1 Silverstone Precision PS02B Black Mid Tower Case

Default Products 1 *3XS 5200 OC* 1 Gigabyte GA-EP43-S3L - Intel P43 1 Scan 3XS System - 1year Onsite Warranty (Mainland UK) 1 Scan System Configuration

CPU 1 Intel Pentium Dual-Core, E5200, 2.5GHz @ 3.75GHz

CPU Coolers 1 Scythe Kama Angle Ultra Quiet CPU Cooler

Memory 1 4GB (2x2GB) Corsair TwinX XMS2, DDR2 PC2-6400 (800), CAS 5

NVIDIA Graphics 1 896MB EVGA GTX 260 SSC, 626 Mhz GPU, 190 Cores, 2106MHz GDDR3

Power Supply Unit 1 650W NorthQ Black Magic Flex Compact Modular PSU 80%+ Eff

System Drives 1 750 GB Samsung Spinpoint F1, 7200 rpm, 32MB Cache

Storage Hard drives 1 *Storage Hard Drive Not Required*

Floppy Drive / Flash Card Readers & Writers 1 Scan 81-in-1 3.5" Internal All-in-One Card Reader + 1 x Front USB

DVD Writer 1 Pioneer DVR-216DBK 20x DVD±R, 12x DVD±DL, DVD+RW x8/-RW x6, SATA, Black
 
name='cl0ck_ed' said:
Thanks, it is a beast of a cpu for the money, and alot of fun to overclock. Pure and simple value for money.

i got my 5200 for £35 what a bargain, cant go wrong when it beats all the athlons hands down
 
Great review and some nice benchmarks. I have to say I was suprised to see a 4+ghz OC, its an amazing budget CPU. IMHO the best thing is the 12.5x multiplier which means you can get a good OC with pretty much any 775 mobo with FSB & voltage control.

I own the older version of that Gigabyte mobo the GA-P31-DS3L and run a E2180 on it @ 2.88ghz (288mhz x 10 @ 1.425v) and it won't go higher without more volts so the E5200 is excellent.
 
@Maccer101

Thanks for the comment, yes the e5200 is a great cpu, had a play with my brothers chip today and it is very different, his can do more than 350 fsb and doesn't like half multies. My chip on the other hand has a fsb wall of about 348 and loves the 12.5 multi.

Remember that 4.35ghz oc was very high voltage, 1.55-6v if i recall.
 
Back
Top