Problem with 9600GT (PCI-E Link @ x1)

Phoenix89

New member
gpuzhf7.png


Hi all.

I'm having a problem with my PCI-E link been at 8x or lower when its a full 16x board supposedly (not SLI) :(

Its a Palit 9600GT 512mb with a Core/Shader/Mem of 650/1625/950(1900 effective).

My pci-e link speed sometimes fluctuates too, not while i'm using it, but after a reboot or two it changes.

It might be all well and good at 16x at some time, then it will drop to 8x and a popular one at the moment is 1x.

Obviously the performace difference between 8x and 16x is negligible if at all noticeable even on these more recent cards.

However, 1x as you can imagine is crippling, my framerates literally drop to under 50%.

Another thing that happens is my motherboard sometimes (not all the time, maybe every few attempts) emits a series of bleeps when I try to start up the system.

My motherboard is an 'MSI K9N Neo V3'. It therefore uses an AMI bios. I have located a site where I could reference the bleep codes and it (one short followed by 8)

points to a 'Cannot write to frame-buffer' problem. From what i've looked at this either means a graphics card problem (damn, got it of ebay), or the motherboard.

The latter I can send back as its not the best board anyway. Oh, also there was nothing on the screen during the bleeps, probably an obvious fact as it wasn't post-ing at all.

I'm wondering if its got anything to do with the fact that the card is PCI-E 2.0 and the board is natively PCI-E 1.0. I know the cards and backwards compatible,

but all the same, the mainboard might have compatibility issues that I'm not aware of. I tried replacing RAM (OCZ DDR-800 platinum rev. 2) just out of curiosity but no fix there.

I then tried the graphics card in a friends Intel mainboard (775i65gz I believe) which is also just a PCI-E 1.0 board, but it boots up with no problems at all.

Also the PCI-E 16x bus works at the full 16x link speed. So I keep saying to myself that it cannot be the graphics card, even though those bios bleeps are very convincing.

I have yet to change PSU although it should be quite sufficient giving out 30amps across the 12v rail and having a rating of 550w. As the 9600GT geberally speaking needs a min of 26 this should be fine.

I'll try this anyway.

To summarize then, and make it a bit easier to comprehend...

...What I have tried all with no avail:

- Flashed the bios to latest release

- Re-flashed the bios to an earlier release (yeah, lol)

- Cleared the cmos more times than I can remember

- Changed bios settings...that should do for the bios...

- Reseated graphics card and other components like RAM

- Swapped PSU's own PCI-E power cable for a molex-to-6pin PCI-E converter

- Re-installed VGA drivers fully and cleanly including nforce drivers, well I put WinXP back on again fresh, so this aint the problem

- Looked on the 9600GT card for any obvious signs of defent (missing/damaged components, lent over capacitors, broken off resistors etc)

All that and still no luck.

The only thing that did give me the slightest bit of hope was when I used the friends rig to test the card, in which case the PC booted perfectly, and the link speed remained at 16x after several re-boots.

The PSU wierdly enough is the same as the one I have in my machine, rated at 550W and 30amps on the 12v rail to name a couple of specs.

So i'm thinking after all this that the most likely cause is a dodgy motherboard, at least dodgy in a compatibility-sense with the whole PCI-E 2.0 thing.

I was reading the specs of the PCI-Express 2.0 standard, and it seems that it supports a new features known as 'dynamic link scaling', intelligently adjusting the bus width depending on work load I guess.

However I'm not sure whether this will even take effect without a PCI-Express 2.0 motherboard, or with current drivers/BIOS revisions etc.

But could this be the graphics card not negotiating with the system bus properly and then giving the dodgy bleeps and knocking the link speed down to 8x or 1x?

I will see if the bleeps coincide with the changes in link speed to make doubly sure.

As you can see, I usually type a lot, lol. No stranger to PC's here or modding/enthusiast activities, but this one is a mystery, and a nightmare too!

I have a 'Gigabyte GA-770-DS3' on the way for next week, which natively supports the new PCI-E standard or v2, so i'll see if that makes any difference. Should be more 'compatible' surely, and if you ask me Gigabyte rock lol.

Anyone? Help would be very much appreciated. Topics on the matter seem very scare at present.

~Phoenix
 

Attachments

  • gpu-z.PNG
    gpu-z.PNG
    45.2 KB · Views: 83
Just to nip something in the bud.

U saying ur seeing the x1 as it`s operating @ x1 speed ?

Cos as far as I`m concerned it just means x16 speed x1 slot, 1 slot in use.
 
Thanks for the reply mate.

No it should be x16 @ x16 not x1. GPU-Z shows the current link speed.

I will attach another GPU-Z pic here to show that:

776.jpg


Like I put above, sometimes it starts running at x8, sometimes x1 at random after a reboot.

:(
 
there is deffo something wrong there mate,I had my 8800gt saying the same thing on my old dfi board because it was in the wrong slot,but after a quick google that cant be your problem as you only have on slot.With your other problems at starting I would check to see if your bios is up to date,if it is i would think of maybe an RMA
 
Yeah he`s done some bios stuff.

Got confused with that everest thing.

Some1 on here had a similar problem and made a thread (bet it was nepas >.<)
 
Cheers for the post nepas. Wierd isn't it! Never seen anything like it in all my builds.

Yeah I flashed my bios to the latest, also went back to the initial release but all with no luck.

The board is going back anyway. I'll had some other stuff going in the post, and I happen to have a Gigabyte board on the way (I detailed in the first post).

Hope it is the board as opposed to the card.

Cheers.

*EDIT*

name='Rastalovich' said:
Got confused with that everest thing.

Hehe, its just showing the same result as GPU-Z to rule out any software bugs.

God knows what the info means after the link speeds though.
 
I heard somewhere (probably nepas` thread again or who-ever), that cards as new as 8800GT+ (so possibly 9600) had to undergo a firmware upgrade of their own to work on older mobos. How strictly true for the 9600 this is I honestly don`t know. Might be down to something as stoopid as power supplying the pcie slot on older boards, meh.

Thought the dood we knew had their card stuck @ x4 or similar.

Can u test it in another rig ?
 
Had mine stuck at 8x at one point.

Although thats not the same as having it stuck at 4x or below.

I can only just say really remove the card make sure no damage on pci-e connector give it a nice blow to get out any possible dust and boot it up again. Then do a new motherboard bios flash.

Cant think of what would be wrong. Just one of those things I guess.
 
Yeah, cheers guys.

Already done bios updates though before I made first post.

And I tested the card in other rig, works spot-on. Starts up without any wierd beeps and the pci-e link speed is at x16 on every restart.

The board I tried it in is the standard pci-e 1.0 as well, and the bios it uses is an award bios, so it won't issue any bios 'bleeps' if anything is wrong, although it still should hang on a black screen if the card was faulty surely.

I'm pretty sure (hoping anyway) that its the mobo, which i'm sending back anyway. Its crap if i'm quite honest. I'll report back with my findings once I get the gigabyte mobo in, all been well, tuesday.

As for flashing the cards bios, well I'd rather not if i'm honest. I can't find any other bios's for 9600GT anyway, and thats if I could get nibitor to back up my old one, and then somehow get nvflash to write me a new one into it. All seems a tadge too unpredictable and risky at this stage with this card... well all pci-e cards anyway as I understand it.

Good to be a part of OC3D!
 
would seem that its your board playing games then,hopefully when you swap yor board everything should be ok
 
Yeah, i'm thinking so.

Oh, I forced my OCZ RAM to run at 533mhz and that has eliminated the bleeping, PC starts up fine. Must be another case of a mobo having compatibility issues with OCZ platinum sticks.

PCI-E problem still there, still all over the place of course :(

Ahh well.... 2 days time i'll have an answer, and hopefully some piece of mind.

Failing that, I have a nice big window to my left....
 
PCI-E 1.0

Explains it, there are problems with these cards working with that. Dont know all teh details but this is most likely the issue.
 
name='Hatman' said:
PCI-E 1.0

Explains it, there are problems with these cards working with that. Dont know all teh details but this is most likely the issue.

eh?

my old 939 lanparty board was only pci-e 1.0 and the only problem i had was when i put the gfx card in the wrong slot
 
Yeah I'm not so sure about that hatman.

In general PCI-E 2.0 cards are supposed to be perfectly fine with old 1.0 standard. They are said to be fully backwards compatible.

However, in my case it 'aint. I'll know by tommorow. Will let you all know.

To be honest a K9N-Neo-v3, lol, you know.... ah well a new gigabyte in tommorow and i'll report back.
 
I think you're thinking of 1.1. Which is used on almost all boards.

And there were problems with 1.0.

Just what I heard.
 
Yeah, i'm just referring to it as 1.0, when technically it is 1.1. No big worries there :-)

Couple of hours, my board should be hear. Gimme an hour or so to re-build my rig and i'll report back..
 
Ok guys, so i'm back.

Fitted my brand-spanking new GA-MA770-DS3 and got it all hooked back up.

Guess what, same problem!!! how the heck?!! I'm seriously on the verge of going ape on this machine. I just want a computer that flippin' works...but no..can't have that.

New mainboard, supposedly PCI-E 2.0 complient and all...still runs at x4 speed, then it might go x8 if i'm lucky...then maybe x1... its an absolute joke!

The CPU and Memory have been in and out, shook about, torture tested, the works...they come back fine.

The graphics card has been tried in another machine and it works flawlessly at x16 speed every single time...which is why it can't be the card... well I don't see how it can be.

But all other components are supposedly fine too... i've been through the bios, i've updated stuff...but regardless of any drivers, and bios at the default, it should be operating at the proper x16 speed.

The card is a Palit 9600GT like I mentioned before... its slightly different to most other brands because of a so-called '3-Phase' Power Design.... which leads me back to the PSU in my comp.... could that be acting up? Fluctuating current/voltage, maybe on the 12v rail? Would that could it to fall back to wierd speeds?

I can't try a PSU immediately, but i'll do it as soon as possible.

Any more ideas guys? This is virtually a new system build...and well i'm utterly stumped...good and proper :-(

*EDIT*

Borrowed another PSU from a friend. Same problem. So it aint power related. It only leaves the card to be faulty. Strange that it works on another rig though...and mine virtually is new now, with the new board etc. I'll live I guess. Just have to try a new 9600GT and go again...
 
sorry to hear the board didnt fix your problem mate,looks like its down to the card not liking you,lol
 
Aww...damn...mate i'm gutted!

I mean how wierd is that... how bad can my luck get.

Well I got one thing out of it, I found that all my other components work fine, so its all eliminated out and left the card. I'll try not to think about it operating fine in that other comp @ x16 because i've got a bad enough headache as it is.

That'll go down as one of them mysteries that you'll never sort out... well at least I won't :p

Hey, lol, if I get another 9600GT (different brand an all of course) and it still does it...ermm...i'll be scrambling back here to let you know.

For now at least...i'll have to put up with the wierd link speed and black screen start-ups.

Thanks for all the input guys...much appreciated. I didn't expect half the response I got here. Good stuff.
 
Back
Top