Ok i second that. Electrical tape didnt fix it. Seems i needed to look a little closer at the problem. Hopefully, with a Google anybody with the same problem can see this thread and fix theirs too without BS from Creative. (For Google: Broken Fatal1ty 1010)
ANyways, seems that upon close inspection the micro button is made of hard plastic, and the contact of the big button you push on is soft plastic. In other words, with some hxc gamage its gonna leave a groove. THat makes it so it double clicks, triple clicks, and sometims dosent click at all! A little dap of some Loctite quick dry super glue and a good smear with a nail file will fill the gap and make it hard plastic.That way there, in about 5 minutes your back to hxc gaming with no worries of missing that headshot! I suggest doing all 3 at the same time so your right click and 5th click dosent do the same thing.
Im testing this tomorrow after i get some sleep and will report back after some BF2 and CSS game play. Im using it now though, and after about 6 months woth of the clicking BS its gone. Im super happy so far for the 20 minutes ive been using it.